"Landmark prosecution" results in Australia's first conviction for misuse of the title 'surgeon'
After pleading guilty in the Parramatta Local Court to one count of using the title ‘surgeon’, a Sydney cosmetic doctor has become the first person to be convicted of falsely claiming to be a surgeon, following what Ahpra calls a “landmark prosecution”.
Under Section 115A of the Health Practitioner Regulation National Law 2010, a medical practitioner must not knowingly or recklessly take or use the title ‘surgeon’ unless they hold specialist registration in the recognised specialty of surgery, obstetrics and gynaecology, ophthalmology or another recognised specialty in the medical profession with the word “surgeon” in a specialist title for the specialty.
A criminal offence that came into effect on 3 November 2023, misuse of the title ‘surgeon’ is punishable by a maximum fine of $60,000 or three years’ imprisonment, or both. Ahpra identified the doctor in question as illegally using the title of ‘surgeon’, including ‘cosmetic surgeon’, in advertising and promotional materials across multiple platforms, including his business website, LinkedIn, Instagram, TikTok and YouTube accounts.
The man continued to describe himself as a ‘cosmetic surgeon’ — including on signs at his premises, in his business logo used on websites and social media, and on scrubs worn by him and his staff — despite being contacted by Ahpra and advised that his use of the title ‘surgeon’ was illegal. Promoting his clinic, videos of the man and his staff wearing the scrubs were posted to various social media accounts.
On 18 November, the man was sentenced to an eight-month Community Corrections Order and ordered to pay $12,000 in legal costs. “Medical practitioners are placed in a position of significant trust in the community, and they have the capacity to earn significant amounts of money through their marketing and advertising,” Judge David Price said in sentencing.
“They are competing with each other, and it is tempting for them to use a marketing edge to secure more work. Where the regulator identifies misleading marketing or advertising, it is important that there are ramifications for this,” Price added. “The fear they have of being caught must outweigh their drive to take that marketing edge … there is too much potential commercial return.”
Ahpra CEO Justin Untersteiner said Ahpra has worked hard over recent years to “clean up the cosmetic surgery industry”. “We regard any misuse of the title of surgeon as a serious breach of trust and the law, and this prosecution demonstrates the consequences for anyone tempted to do the wrong thing,” Untersteiner said.
“It’s not legal to call yourself a surgeon if you don’t have specific surgical qualifications,” said Dr Susan O’Dwyer, Chair of the Medical Board of Australia. “Doctors who do not have medical surgical qualifications have a responsibility to know and apply that fact. Honesty and lawfulness are basic qualities that patients have a right to expect of all doctors.”
Anyone with concerns about the type of registration of any practitioner can check the online Register of practitioners maintained by Ahpra or call 1300 419 495.
WA's women's, newborn and children's model remains a "major missed opportunity", doctors say
Following WA's announcement of a new dedicated Women and Babies Health Service, AMA (WA)...
National standards for pain management education now available
The standards are designed to better equip health practitioners to assess, manage and support...
Australia invests further $14.6 million in national allergy research
Further funding until June 2028 for the National Allergy Centre of Excellence (NACE) and the...
